User blog comment:Subject 16*/Assassin's Creed: Revelations - News/@comment-71.174.162.193-20110514160037/@comment-3556130-20110515102553

This argument has been raised many times before. The fact is, there's simply no evidence for it. But then again, it could be one of Ubisoft's twists. A more interesting and plausible argument was one raised concerning how Al Maulin stabbed Altair in the stomach to show his 'Re-birth' after breaking the Creed. What if this is why Desmond was forced to stab Lucy. To allow her to be 'Re-born', maybe as Eve.