Welcome to Assassin's Creed Wiki! Log in and join the community.

Board Thread:Wiki discussion/@comment-1828842-20200521221354/@comment-28601337-20200522080326

From the Assassin's Creed Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Merge Vote
Category:Louisiana Y
Category:Documents Y
Category: Massachusetts Y
Levant Y
Sanctuary of Kosmos Y
Assassin's Creed (series)
Guild challenges Y
Genetic memory Y
Boat Y
The Naval Campaign
Greek mythology Y
Seven Years' War Y
Granada War W
Sword of Altaïr Y
Queen Anne's Pistol Y
Pirate Scimitar Y
Hidden Blade X
French Cuttoe Y
Grand Master X
Mentor X
Bounty hunters A
Privateers X
Hybrid Y
Jupiter X

Cris' observations:

  • I agree with the merging the Memory Extraction with Genetic Memory. Because it answers to the question "How they obtain this?, How is it extracted?", and such answer should be in the article itself instead of having its own, it's more "friendly-user" that way IMO.
  • The Assassin Gauntlet page shouldn't be merge. The Hidden Blade article lists all the modifications available, but techniques, combat and stuff applied with such modification should be detailed in their own article.
  • I understand that Assassin leaders were the "boss" of a certain little group inside a specific Brotherhood, and the Mentor was the ultimate boss. Same with the Templars. According to this, I don't think they should be merged, both are bosses but within the hierarchy, they are very different. And merging them with the Master Assassin article is also troublesome because we don't know which of them got said rank. We should wait and leave it as it is. One thing I'd do, tho, is remove Bayek from the "Egyptian Brotherhood" section and create a new one called: Egyptian Branch of the Hidden Ones, and put Bayek there. Same with Amunet but in another section: Roman Branch of the Hidden Ones.
  • About the bounty hunters and pirate hunters. Idk. I thought the former were paid by the Crown in Rogue, and the latter were pirate hunters searching for other weak pirates without representing any kind of goverment but their own. I'm not sure abou this.
  • About the privateers, I'll have to say no to this one. The avatar's page describes all the stuff you can do with it in the multiplayer, the other is an article describing what they did in history, two very different things.
  • The thing creating trouble is what we know about "Zeus" in Fate of Atlantis. The proof we have that indicates they are two different individuals is that Jupiter is mentioned in the DLC by his other name: Tinia and Zeus is called as such in the Isu codex titled "A Tale of Brothers". In this one, the Archivist talks about Zeus and how much he was hated by his brothers. It's also mentioned that while Poseidon was in charge, he activated the mechanisms to start a new cycle (sink the city and rise it again) just to eliminate Zeus' smell after his visit. The hate is palpable. If Poseidon hated Zeus so much, he wouldn't allow him to have his own chamber (Tinia's archive) in the city until the last cycle that would destroy Atlantis.