Board Thread:Off-topic board/@comment-5320677-20160117161434

This is just a thought I had, who would win in an all out ship battle, then afterward, a straight sword/pistol duel.

Both combatants have full upgrades on their armor and their ships as well

Shay has his longsword and he's wearing his Templar coat, his guns are the English Percussion Pistols

Edward is wielding the pirate cutlasses and has a full brace of cannon pistols, he's wearing the assassin robes.

Persnally, I think than in the sea battle, it would be a pretty close match, with the Morrigan gaining a speed advantage, and would ultimeatly outpace the heavier Jackdaw. However, the Jackdaw would probably win out due to it's raw power.

Now, Edward Kenway against Shay Cormac, in a straight duel it would, again, be close. But, I personally think that Shay would win with his more practical fighting style.

I would like to hear your opinions on this matter.<ac_metadata title="Jackdaw against Morrigan, Shay against Edward Who would win?"> </ac_metadata>