Alonzo Batilla's fisheries

Over the course of his time in the West Indies during the early 18th century, the pirate Alonzo Batilla often left his ship to go fishing on a rowboat, fishing many exotic fish, which he caught by using specialized hooks.

Captured fish

Bone hook

• 
  Sergeant Major - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Blue Tang - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Ocean Surgeonfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Trumpetfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Bonito - Rarity: Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Honeycomb Cowfish - Rarity: Rare, Size: Small
• 
  Nassau Grouper - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Goliath Grouper - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Medium

Red hook

• 
  Spanish Hogfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Schoolmaster - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Bar Jack - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Porcupinefish - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Spotted Moray Eel - Rarity: Rare, Size: Small
• 
  Spotted Scorpion fish - Rarity: Rare, Size Small
• 
  Red Hind - Rarity: Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Blue Marlin - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large

Blue hook

• 
  Gray Snapper - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Yellowtail Snapper - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Queen Angelfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Atlantic Wolfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Barracuda - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Harlequin Bass - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Hogfish - Rarity: Rare, Size: Large
• 
  White-spotted Eagle Ray - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large

Bronze hook

• 
  Coney - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Barred Hamlet - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Tiger Grouper - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Skipjack Tuna - Rarity: Common, Size: Large
• 
  Yellowfin Tuna - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Peacock Flounder - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  White Marlin - Rarity: Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Angler - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Medium

Silver hook

• 
  Graysby - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Bluestriped Grunt - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Horse-eye Jack - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Golden Dorado - Rarity: Common, Size: Large
• 
  Green Moray Eel - Rarity: Rare, Size: Small
• 
  Lionfish - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Rainbow Parrotfish - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Coelacanth - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large

Gold hook

• 
  Palometa - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Rock Beauty - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Mahogany Snapper - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Kingfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Large
• 
  Tarpon - Rarity: Rare, Size: Large
• 
  White-spotted Filefish - Rarity: Rare, Size: Small
• 
  Stingray - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Blacktip Reef Shark - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large

Shiny hook

• 
  Frogfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Comet fish - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Soapfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Slippery Dick - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Glasseye Snapper - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Pipefish - Rarity: Rare, Size: Small
• 
  Sailfish - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Sand Tiger Shark - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large

Platinium hook

• 
  Peppermint Angelfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Masked Angelfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Spotted Goatfish - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Spotted Drum - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  French Angelfish - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Sharksucker - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Skate - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Black Grouper - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large

Dragon hook

• 
  Bermuda Chub - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Bluehead Wrasse - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  French Grunt - Rarity: Common, Size: Small
• 
  Humpback Grouper - Rarity: Common, Size: Medium
• 
  Highhat - Rarity: Rare, Size: Small
• 
  Bi-color Damselfish - Rarity: Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Queen Triggerfish - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Hammerhead Shark - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Medium

Ultimate hook

• 
  Blackfin Tuna - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Medium
• 
  Electric Ray - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Green sea turtle - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Goblin Shark - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Manta Ray - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Basking Shark - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Large
• 
  Midnight Parrotfish - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Small
• 
  Yellow Stingray - Rarity: Very Rare, Size: Small

Other Catches

• 
  Broken Bottle
• 
  Old Boot
• 
  Worm-eaten Plank

Reference

• Assassin's Creed: Pirates