Board Thread:Wiki discussion/@comment-5019018-20170811014154: Difference between revisions
imported>The Crimson Eagle Created page with "I think we as a wiki need to reconsider how we've been doing era icons for the past ten years. So far, we have one icon for every piece of media -- every game, every comic, ev..." |
imported>The Crimson Eagle No edit summary |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
I think we as a wiki need to reconsider how we've been doing era icons for the past ten years. So far, we have one icon for every piece of media -- every game, every comic, every book, | I think we as a wiki need to reconsider how we've been doing era icons for the past ten years. So far, we have one icon for every piece of media -- every game, every comic, every book, every film, and more. So it's basically a catalogue of appearances by this point. However, it's starting to get a bit absurd, as this series is approaching its tenth main instalment. Look at [[Humans]], [[Assassins]], or [[Templars]]. There are so many era icons on these articles that it requires two lines to fit them all, and I think that's a bit much. | ||
With this in mind, I think we need to think of a new system for era icons. Or cut back on what we have. I can think of a view ways of doing this: | With this in mind, I think we need to think of a new system for era icons. Or cut back on what we have. I can think of a view ways of doing this: | ||
#Just get rid of era icons altogether. I don't know what purpose they serve that isn't accomplished by Appearances and References. | #Just get rid of era icons altogether. I don't know what purpose they serve that isn't accomplished by Appearances and References. | ||
#Cut down the era icons to "Games", "Novels", "Films", etc., so that while we are showing what form of media the article subject exists in, | #Cut down the era icons to "Games", "Novels", "Films", etc., so that while we are showing what form of media the article subject exists in, we aren't going overboard by listing everything it's in. | ||
#Use actual eras, a la Wookieepedia. Wookieepedia has era icons for the Old Republic, Rise of the Empire, and Rebellion eras, just to name a few. They're also placed in the same space in the title, so they don't actually take up article space like we do. | #Use actual eras, a la Wookieepedia. Wookieepedia has era icons for the Old Republic, Rise of the Empire, and Rebellion eras, just to name a few. They're also placed in the same space in the title, so they don't actually take up article space like we do. | ||
But those are just my suggestions. If anyone else has any, I'm all ears, but I do think something should be done sooner rather than later.<ac_metadata title="Era icons"> </ac_metadata> | But those are just my suggestions. If anyone else has any, I'm all ears, but I do think something should be done sooner rather than later.<ac_metadata title="Era icons"> </ac_metadata> | ||
Latest revision as of 00:22, 9 October 2017
I think we as a wiki need to reconsider how we've been doing era icons for the past ten years. So far, we have one icon for every piece of media -- every game, every comic, every book, every film, and more. So it's basically a catalogue of appearances by this point. However, it's starting to get a bit absurd, as this series is approaching its tenth main instalment. Look at Humans, Assassins, or Templars. There are so many era icons on these articles that it requires two lines to fit them all, and I think that's a bit much.
With this in mind, I think we need to think of a new system for era icons. Or cut back on what we have. I can think of a view ways of doing this:
- Just get rid of era icons altogether. I don't know what purpose they serve that isn't accomplished by Appearances and References.
- Cut down the era icons to "Games", "Novels", "Films", etc., so that while we are showing what form of media the article subject exists in, we aren't going overboard by listing everything it's in.
- Use actual eras, a la Wookieepedia. Wookieepedia has era icons for the Old Republic, Rise of the Empire, and Rebellion eras, just to name a few. They're also placed in the same space in the title, so they don't actually take up article space like we do.
But those are just my suggestions. If anyone else has any, I'm all ears, but I do think something should be done sooner rather than later.<ac_metadata title="Era icons"> </ac_metadata>