Welcome to Assassin's Creed Wiki! Log in and join the community.

Board Thread:Wiki discussion/@comment-1828842-20200521221354/@comment-27435762-20200522143526

From the Assassin's Creed Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Except for a handful of candidates, I'm in support of all the proposed merges. My own notes are as follows, but in the end, I'll side with Sol for any disputes.

Naval Campaign

If we're to differentiate between the gameplay mechanic and the actions of Shay's fleet in the Seven Years' War, shouldn't we do the same for Edward's fleet in the Golden Age of Piracy? I don't have AC4, so I don't know.

Reconquista

I agree with Lacrosse: hold off on merging it for now until we get info from Valhalla, if any. Otherwise, I vote "yes".

Mentor / Grand Master

I feel "X leader" is too generic a title to keep. As has roughly already been said, Mentors / Grand Masters are leaders, but not all leaders are Mentors / Grand Masters. I vote "yes".

Privateer / Hunters

Like Sol, I think "privateer" should be about the actual position not the Animi Avatar, which should have its own page like the other Avatars do. I disagree that pirate hunters are separate from privateers for the exact reason Sol said, that not every hunter would have to own Letters of Marque. Surely there were opportunistic kills of "regular" pirates without official support.

Jupiter

Overall, I vote "yes". The only thing I can think of to reconcile the name confusion is that Poseidon cooled his temper a long while after sinking Atlantis to clean it of Zeus germs and chose to dedicate a room to Jupiter, who (for some reason??) returned to using his old Etruscan name. However, it seems out-of-character given millennia of bad blood.