Board Thread:Wiki discussion/@comment-6517-20190219121823/@comment-18014300-20190221091927: Difference between revisions
imported>Sol Pacificus Created page with "<div class="quote">Francesco75 wrote:<br />I think it depend of the context, if we said during the American Revolution or the Renaissance, don't need to use CE, and if it's du..." |
m Text replacement - "<br />" to "<br>" |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
<div class="quote">Francesco75 wrote:<br | <div class="quote">Francesco75 wrote:<br>I think it depend of the context, if we said during the American Revolution or the Renaissance, don't need to use CE, and if it's during Antiquity as in Rome, Greece or Egypt, used CE or BCE. | ||
But in my personal opinion, | But in my personal opinion, I find difficulties to use the term common era. Myself I make History studies and I know many countries use the gregorian calendar as civil calendar and some people today could be offended to see the terms "Before Christ" or "Anno Domini", but i find a bit ironical and hypocritical to used a christian calendar, erasing the fact it used the birth of the Christ as the beginning of it and saying later it's the common era. It must use another point in history for the common era, as the apparition of human life, the beginning of writing or something else. | ||
It's also posed a problem with the other calendars. | It's also posed a problem with the other calendars. In Black Flag, the date used are from the Gregorian or the Julian calendar as Great Britain didn't use the Gregorian one before 1752? | ||
</div> | </div> | ||
I'm not entirely sure if this is relevant to the thread, but yeah, I understand that controversy surrounding the usage of the Common Era notation, and to be honest, both sides have valid arguments. There's no easy answer to it, so I guess we just follow by convention. | I'm not entirely sure if this is relevant to the thread, but yeah, I understand that controversy surrounding the usage of the Common Era notation, and to be honest, both sides have valid arguments. There's no easy answer to it, so I guess we just follow by convention. | ||
Latest revision as of 00:19, 13 July 2026
I think it depend of the context, if we said during the American Revolution or the Renaissance, don't need to use CE, and if it's during Antiquity as in Rome, Greece or Egypt, used CE or BCE.
But in my personal opinion, I find difficulties to use the term common era. Myself I make History studies and I know many countries use the gregorian calendar as civil calendar and some people today could be offended to see the terms "Before Christ" or "Anno Domini", but i find a bit ironical and hypocritical to used a christian calendar, erasing the fact it used the birth of the Christ as the beginning of it and saying later it's the common era. It must use another point in history for the common era, as the apparition of human life, the beginning of writing or something else.
It's also posed a problem with the other calendars. In Black Flag, the date used are from the Gregorian or the Julian calendar as Great Britain didn't use the Gregorian one before 1752?
I'm not entirely sure if this is relevant to the thread, but yeah, I understand that controversy surrounding the usage of the Common Era notation, and to be honest, both sides have valid arguments. There's no easy answer to it, so I guess we just follow by convention.