Welcome to Assassin's Creed Wiki! Log in and join the community.
User talk:Althyk: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
imported>Althyk Reply |
imported>Misphantom |
||
| Line 6: | Line 6: | ||
Hey Klad, take this as no offense, but why did you place the Mary Ann Nichols (Assassin) page as a candidate for deletion? You could easily change its title instead. It sounds a bit like badge hunting and its not allowed here. Besides, you can't name it as British Assassin because there are 4 other British Assassins undercover as prostitutes. If you have problems about it, please say it to the article's talk page. [[User:Misphantom|Misphantom]] ([[User talk:Misphantom|talk]]) 06:46, December 20, 2015 (UTC) | Hey Klad, take this as no offense, but why did you place the Mary Ann Nichols (Assassin) page as a candidate for deletion? You could easily change its title instead. It sounds a bit like badge hunting and its not allowed here. Besides, you can't name it as British Assassin because there are 4 other British Assassins undercover as prostitutes. If you have problems about it, please say it to the article's talk page. [[User:Misphantom|Misphantom]] ([[User talk:Misphantom|talk]]) 06:46, December 20, 2015 (UTC) | ||
:Remember that, throughout the DLC, only the victim 'Mary Jane Kelly' was concretely identified as an Assassin initiate in disguise. The others could have either been the real prostitutes or Jacob's initiates; either way, in their case, it's not confirmed. As such, with 'Mary Jane Kelly' being the only one identified as another person entirely--as an Assassin initiate of the British Brotherhood--moving the page to 'British Assassin' would suffice; it's consistent with the nomenclature for unidentified Assassins from specific branches. The other prostitutes can have their article entries under their actual names, as they weren't specifically confirmed to have been the actual courtesans, which is reflected in their database entries. [[User:Klad|klad]] ([[User talk:Klad|talk]]) 07:06, December 20, 2015 (UTC) | :Remember that, throughout the DLC, only the victim 'Mary Jane Kelly' was concretely identified as an Assassin initiate in disguise. The others could have either been the real prostitutes or Jacob's initiates; either way, in their case, it's not confirmed. As such, with 'Mary Jane Kelly' being the only one identified as another person entirely--as an Assassin initiate of the British Brotherhood--moving the page to 'British Assassin' would suffice; it's consistent with the nomenclature for unidentified Assassins from specific branches. The other prostitutes can have their article entries under their actual names, as they weren't specifically confirmed to have been the actual courtesans, which is reflected in their database entries. [[User:Klad|klad]] ([[User talk:Klad|talk]]) 07:06, December 20, 2015 (UTC) | ||
:::The databases of the murder of other prostitutes such as [[Database: The Murder of Catherine Eddowes|Catherine Eddowes]], states (not directly) that Jacob had sent his initiates to take the identities of the original prostitutes. Those murder databases which indicates "lost rings" signifies that Evie took the Assassin rings with her. | |||
:::I understand the renaming of the articles as "British Assassins" and I sort of agree with you but like I said, there are a couple Assassin undercover as prostitutes so we can't really name them as British Assassin 1 or British Assassin 2. Don't worry, I'll ask the staff about it. | |||
:::But really, you could just rename it in the first place and not create another page, which is easier. | |||
:::Anyway thanks for your reply to clear things out :) -[[User:Misphantom|Misphantom]] ([[User talk:Misphantom|talk]]) 07:22, December 20, 2015 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 09:22, 20 December 2015
Welcome
Welcome to the Order, Althyk! |
Welcome to the Assassin's Creed Wiki!
We hope you enjoy your stay, and we look forward to working with you! |
| Have you something to say? |
|
We seek unity, stability and order. |
|
| We wish you safety and peace on your future endeavors. Happy Editing! |
Feel free to contact me on my talkpage if you need anything. Amnestyyy (talk) 17:46, June 16, 2014 (UTC)
Mary Ann Nichols
Hey Klad, take this as no offense, but why did you place the Mary Ann Nichols (Assassin) page as a candidate for deletion? You could easily change its title instead. It sounds a bit like badge hunting and its not allowed here. Besides, you can't name it as British Assassin because there are 4 other British Assassins undercover as prostitutes. If you have problems about it, please say it to the article's talk page. Misphantom (talk) 06:46, December 20, 2015 (UTC)
- Remember that, throughout the DLC, only the victim 'Mary Jane Kelly' was concretely identified as an Assassin initiate in disguise. The others could have either been the real prostitutes or Jacob's initiates; either way, in their case, it's not confirmed. As such, with 'Mary Jane Kelly' being the only one identified as another person entirely--as an Assassin initiate of the British Brotherhood--moving the page to 'British Assassin' would suffice; it's consistent with the nomenclature for unidentified Assassins from specific branches. The other prostitutes can have their article entries under their actual names, as they weren't specifically confirmed to have been the actual courtesans, which is reflected in their database entries. klad (talk) 07:06, December 20, 2015 (UTC)
- The databases of the murder of other prostitutes such as Catherine Eddowes, states (not directly) that Jacob had sent his initiates to take the identities of the original prostitutes. Those murder databases which indicates "lost rings" signifies that Evie took the Assassin rings with her.
- I understand the renaming of the articles as "British Assassins" and I sort of agree with you but like I said, there are a couple Assassin undercover as prostitutes so we can't really name them as British Assassin 1 or British Assassin 2. Don't worry, I'll ask the staff about it.
- But really, you could just rename it in the first place and not create another page, which is easier.
- Anyway thanks for your reply to clear things out :) -Misphantom (talk) 07:22, December 20, 2015 (UTC)

