User:Soranin/Sandbox2

Empty Table

Merge	Vote
Category:Louisiana
Category:Documents
Category: Massachusetts
Levant
Sanctuary of Kosmos
Assassin's Creed (series)
Guild challenges
Genetic memory
Boat
The Naval Campaign
Greek mythology
Seven Years' War
Granada War
Sword of Altaïr
Queen Anne's Pistol
Pirate Scimitar
Hidden Blade
French Cuttoe
Grand Master
Mentor
Bounty hunters
Privateers
Hybrid
Jupiter

Tallying up

• Y: Agree with merge
• X: Disagree with merge
• A: Ambivalent
• O: Other proposal
• W: Wait
• : Abstain

Merge	Soranin	Lacrosse	Vilka	Sol	Cris	Sal	Darman	ACsenior	Zero
Category:Louisiana	Y		Y	Y	Y		Y	Y	W
Category:Documents	Y	O	O	Y	Y		Y	Y	Y
Category: Massachusetts	Y		Y	Y	Y		Y	Y	W
Levant	Y	Y	X	Y	Y		Y	Y	Y
Sanctuary of Kosmos	Y	O	Y	A	Y		Y	Y	Y
Assassin's Creed (series)	O	O	Y	O			Y		O
Guild challenges	Y	Y	Y	Y	Y		Y	Y	O
Genetic memory	Y		X	Y	Y		Y	Y	Y
Boat	Y	Y	X	Y	Y		Y	Y	Y
The Naval Campaign	X	O	X	W			?*	X	A
Greek mythology	X	X	X	X	Y	X	Y	X	X
Seven Years' War	Y	Y	A	Y	Y		Y	Y	Y
Granada War	X	X	A	X	W		W	A	Y
Sword of Altaïr	Y		Y	Y	Y		Y	Y	X
Queen Anne's Pistol	Y		Y	Y	Y		Y	Y	Y
Pirate Scimitar	A		Y	Y	Y		Y	Y	Y
Hidden Blade	A		X	X	X		Y	A	Y
French Cuttoe	A		Y	O	Y		Y	Y	X
Grand Master	X	X	A	Y	X		Y	Y	O
Mentor	X	X	A	Y	X		Y	Y	O
Bounty hunters	Y		Y	X	A		Y	Y	Y
Privateers	X	Y	Y	Y*	X		X	Y	X
Hybrid	W	X	Y	A	Y		Y	X	O
Jupiter	A	Y	Y	A	X		Y	Y	Y

Lacrosse's Os

• Category:Documents - counterproposal historical documents renamed documents with document collections a subcategory within that
• I think it would make sense to merge them under Cave of Gaia as it would be the larger structure that includes the Sanctuary of Kosmos.
• Assassin's Creed (series) - I really like your proposal of make the former the gallery page of the latter

• I suggest renaming twelve gods to Greek pantheon so as to encompass titans, lesser deities, beings like nymphs, etc

• Naval Campaign - naval campaign should be formatted to annotate how the information is presented through the Animus and Shay’s fleet deleted

• Weapon pages - these are sticky ones because we need to decide whether they were actual tangible weapons and then the exact same weapons or just mods; Altair’s Swords might be able to go into the original page under legacy as mods being provided by Abstergo; the others I believe are separate weapons which should be kept separate (unless we go with my radical proposal that we treat all weapons including their stats as animus generated models but that’s a discussion for another day

• Hidden Blade - I abstain as long we are consistent with all the variants and attachments

Vilka's O

• Category:Documents to Category:Document collections.

Sol's Notes

• Assassin leader and Templar leader should just be deleted. There is too much overlap with "Mentor" and "Grand Master of the Templar Order" respectively.
• For the weapon pages, we already decided upon a comprehensive guideline on organizing weapon articles years ago and the matter has already long been settled. Two weapons which are actually entirely identical in appearance are essentially one weapon which appears in more than one game, just as one character or location may appear in more than one game. They should always be merged, and many weapon pages have already been merged under this policy. On the other hand, two weapons which happen to share the same name but are clearly different warrant two separate pages. Hence, we merged the Scimitar of Assassin's Creed II with the Persian Shamshir of Revelations, but did not merge Persian Scimitars into them.
• "Assassin Gauntlet" should be kept, but it needs to be corrected to "Assassin gauntlet" because it is a general noun, it needs to be rewritten with the correct definition, and a separate page needs to be created for "rope launcher".
• Per policy, "Cuttoe Sword (Assassin's Creed III)" and "Cuttoe Sword (Liberation)" should be merged together because they appear to be the same model of sword, "French Cuttoe" should remain a separate page because it's clearly a different model, and "Cuttoe sword" should be a general page on cuttoe swords.
• A case can be made that pirate hunters and privateers aren't necessarily the same, and that would be the reason to keep them separate, but I'm not sure about that. I guess technically not every pirate hunter may have a letter of marque from a government legally sanctioning their pirate hunting?

Darman's Notes

• If we're to differentiate between the gameplay mechanic and the actions of Shay's fleet in the Seven Years' War, shouldn't we do the same for Edward's fleet in the Golden Age of Piracy? I don't have AC4, so I don't know.

Zero's Notes

• For the Category merges, I do have a couple of questions: do we have a defined policy on location categories? What do we normally do for states/provinces/territories within countries? What sort of granularity do we want?
• For the first one (→ Assassin's Creed (series)), I would be remiss to not mention that I've spent... some time fixing up the Games and Media page and would be slightly saddened to see it disappear. Having said that, it is perfectly logical to merge these two, whether the template established in Games and Media gets ported to a gallery page or not, Games and Media as it currently is is redundant.
• I think that if we were to merge the Guild challenges we should also merge the Club challenges from ACIII
• Now, onto the → Mentor and → Grandmaster merges... I decidedly believe that they don't need to be merged, rather at best the non-merging pages renamed to clarify that Templar leader and Assassin leader aren't... titles unlike Grand Master and Mentor.

• As for the → Hybrid merge... I believe that the whole thing is a gross mischaracterisation of what a "Hybrid" is. Yes, I believe they should be merged, though under what name I am unsure. […] I believe these are just different terms for the same type of person: a Human with Isu ancestry. While I do believe these should be merged, I also believe this should be clarified.