Assassin's Creed Wiki:Bureau/MembersNom

2010-10-31T17:40:24Z

121.54.54.34: /* Campbell430 */

{{/Header}}

<div style="border:2px solid #800000; padding:.5em 1em 1em 1em; border-top:none; background-color:#F2F3F4; color:#000">
[[File:Acsymbol box.jpg|100px|right]]
This page is dedicated to '''nominating''' potential new Istruttores. '''Current members of the Istruttorium''' monitor this page, while the '''Direttore''' manages the voting and nominating process.
----
The '''Istruttori''' are the '''Assassin's Creed Wiki's most trusted users''' and as such, the user to be nominated must meet the following prerequisites.

<big>The user, before nomination, must...</big>
*...know the basic and general facts regarding the [[Assassin's Creed (series)|Assassin's Creed Universe]].
*...have accumulated at least a hundred edits and contributions.
*...be able to write using perfect English grammar and vocabulary.
*…be unbiased, unprejudiced, and fair on all aspects of wiki-related subjects.
*…abide by the [[Assassin's Creed Wiki:WikiPolicies|AC Wiki's policies]].
*…have learned the [[Help:Contents|basics in editing]].
*…be able to cooperate with other users and Istruttores.
*…have patience and persistence on expansions and improvements regarding the wiki.
*…have established a respectful stature and attitude among other users and Istruttores.
*…refrain from adding speculation on articles.
*...be frequently present at the wiki.

Failure to meet at least 3 (three) of the aforementioned prerequisites will result in the cancellation of the voting process.
----

<big>''How to nominate'':</big>

#A user who has met the prerequisites listed above can be nominated by either himself/herself, or by another user.
##If a user is nominated by another user without official consent, it is either the '''nominator''' or the '''Direttore's''' job to notify said user.
##However, if the user declines the nomination, voting will be immediately closed.
#The user's name must be listed at the voting section below the guidelines, followed by a short summary of the user's contributions, and also two sections for both positive and negative votes.
#Once the user has accumulated enough positive or negative votes from other users within 2 (two) week's time, the '''Direttore''', '''Carmelengo''' (or in their absence, ''Admins'') will immediately close the votes.
#If a user fails to gain the favor of other users, he/she can be nominated once more after the closing of the votes. The user/nominator of said user is discouraged to nominate again without valid reason. If the user/nominator fails to cooperate with the said terms, the voting process will be immediately closed by the '''Diretorre'''.
#The user nominated can only be granted rollback rights by the '''[[User:D. Cello|Wiki Bureaucrat]]'''.
('''IMPORTANT NOTE:''' A user can only be nominated ONCE per month. This is to avoid future conflicts regarding users.)

<big>''How to vote:''</big>

#Users (both respected regulars and Istruttori) are allowed to vote in favor or disfavor of the user. Criteria regarding the user should follow subsequently with the vote, be it positive or negative.
##The user nominated and the subsequent nominator of said user are NOT ALLOWED to vote.
#Please note that in order for your vote to count, you must have accumulated at least 50 contributions and edits.
#Criteria regarding the user must be complete and truthful. Unreasoned votes WILL BE INVALIDATED and stroke through.
##The Nominator, Istruttori, and the Direttore are the only ones permitted to strike through invalid votes.
#After 2 (two) week's time, the voting process will be closed by either the '''Direttore''', the '''Admins''' or the '''Wiki Bureaucrat'''. The user's fate depends on the accumulated votes.
##'''If the user has accumulated enough positive votes:''' The user will then be subsequently added onto the official [[Istruttori]] list, and will also be featured in the [[Assassin's Creed Wiki:Staff|Wiki's Staff Panel]].
##'''If the user has accumulated enough negative votes:''' The user will simply resume his/her activities around the wiki.

==[[Istruttori|Istruttori nominations]]==
==[[User:Campbell430|Campbell430]]- Result: Nay==
To quote Jasca Ducato; ''"...you're [Nominated user] an average editor who has earned himself a bit of a name amongst the "higher-uppers", although I wouldn't say it is a particularly good one."''
{{voteclosed}}
'''Did some of the timeline pages. Added some good images. Proven himself more than a medal abuser.''' --[[User:War Clown|'''War''''''Clown''']][[User talk:War Clown|''Wanna Talk?'']] 14:51, October 2, 2010 (UTC)

 <big>'''Yay'''</big>


<strike>
#Well, I nominated him. So that means I vote for him. --[[User:War Clown|'''War''''''Clown''']][[User talk:War Clown|''Wanna Talk?'']] 14:51, October 2, 2010 (UTC)</strike>
*Vote canceled at the behest of D. Cello. --[[User:War Clown|'''War''''''Clown''']][[User talk:War Clown|''Wanna Talk?'']] 04:32, October 3, 2010 (UTC)
#He's a good contributor. And he seems like a pretty good guy. -- [[User:Master Sima Yi|Master Sima Yi]] 20:11, October 2, 2010 (UTC)
#In the beginning he was alittle tough with catagories but redemed himself by working extreamly hard with good edits, i vote yes [[User:DanMan7308|DanMan7308]] 21:25, October 2, 2010 (UTC) DanMan7308

<big>'''Nay'''</big>

#Hmm. Sure he has a lot of edits, but if you'd look at his contribs, are they much different from a normal user? Most of them are "clean ups", removing and adding categories, adding a sentence to the timeline or just adding one image. Now I know we've got two empty spots, but c'mon War, his contribs are mostly "Added space", "moved image" or "added full stop". Plus, if you look at his [http://assassinscreed.wikia.com/index.php?title=Special:Contributions&limit=500&showall=0&target=Campbell430 full contrib list], You'd see that there is''' OVER A MILLION''' blog comments/articles, userpage edits and usertalk discussions, and then after those it goes back to "moved image", etc... For us Istruttori to get noticed we wrote up whole '''WikiProject pages''' (and they're freakin' long), helped Cello with creation of '''Policies''', created''' brand new articles that were important and properly formatted''', fixed the '''IRC '''and many, more. You have to stray away from an average editor to become an Istruttori, and sadly, I don't think Campbell is much different yet. I know most of the current Istruttori (including myself) probably comment around on these talk pages aswell, but most of our contributions are excellent and much needed. I really wouldn't think "Adding some crap to the timeline, or added some good images after being a medal abuser" would qualify as being an Istruttori. You'd have to do better than that. I hope this changes some of your minds that voted for Yay. [[User:The_Theif|'''The Thief ''']] 00:32, October 3, 2010 (UTC)
:::And I hope this changes your mind for voting for Nay. As I said in the nomination's opening statement, he helped out with the timeline pages. Not only that, but he did some of my workload for me during my absence (he added them timeline images Schinnini uploaded to their respective pages) and also uploaded some of his own (great quality too). Plus, he's very active and nearly always present. I'm not about to go against another party's vote, but I felt I needed to get this out in the open. --[[User:War Clown|'''War''''''Clown''']][[User talk:War Clown|''Wanna Talk?'']] 04:32, October 3, 2010 (UTC)
::::No, It doesn't. Adding images to an article while you were absent or adding some images of his own isn't such a big deal to be honest. :P, Plus, alot of normal users update the timeline page. [[User:The_Theif|'''The Thief ''']] 06:42, October 3, 2010 (UTC)
:::::You do know that I'm talking about the Major Events, and not that oh so long page, right? --[[User:War Clown|'''War''''''Clown''']][[User talk:War Clown|''Wanna Talk?'']] 10:38, October 3, 2010 (UTC)
::::::Still, that doesn't really rebut everything else i've said. :P Normal users also edit the Major Event pages, look at the member list and see. XD [[User:The_Theif|'''The Thief ''']] 11:38, October 3, 2010 (UTC)
hi, i dont want to sound too desperate, but i would really like to get in the institutore and have been nominated, but you voted for nay Is there anything i could do to make it a yay. Thanks :D Campbell430 18:58, October 3, 2010 (UTC)

::I don't know, seperate yourself from normal users? I don't know why you're being nominated really. Almost every Istruttori gets nominated for something special, Jasca Ducato had a huge history of rewriting articles to the best standards, and watching over every single move made to them. I had written the Policies and created many more official pages, templates, etc.. War_Clown helped alot with the WikiProjects and created many pages towards it and created templates/more. I guess the only reason I voted nay was because you're just like any other normal user, you haven't done anything really that special. "Added a few images and made a few edits to timeline pages after being a medal abuser" doesn't really seem like Istruttori material, and you don't even know how to spell Istruttori.. so, mhm. I think War's just trying to fill in the gaps into the Istruttori staff panel. So I guess you're lucky no-one really looked into your nomination in detail. You'll probably win the vote, lol. I have no problem with you though, i'll still be friendly. :D [[User:The_Theif|'''The Thief ''']] 21:15, October 3, 2010 (UTC)
2. I'll go with Thief on this one. Campbel, you are a good editor, but so are a lot of other members. And while you've done good things, you're... curriculum of awesome stuff isn't nearly as extensive as I would like a Istruttore's to be. The Istruttorium is a group that by name-definition means they are a higher tier, moderators in power and teachers in mind, and as such, they msut separate themselves from everyone via their fantastic edits skills and judgement. You, for example, write in lower caps oO Don't ake this bad, kid, but I think you are Istruttore material... just not yet. -- [[User:D. Cello|D. Cello]] 21:28, October 3, 2010 (UTC)
3. I'm voting no, his edit history is far from exemplary, just four days ago he made an [http://assassinscreed.wikia.com/index.php?title=Master_Assassin&diff=71540&oldid=71539 extremly pointless and stupid edit] that not only broke the sourcing on the page, but that I consider to be vandalism. A large number of my edits in recent times have been reverts of his own, and although he seems to have stopped with his category plastering and stupid picture placements, he still has a long way to go in my eyes. As Thief said, you're an average editor who has earnt himself a bit of a name amongst the "higher-uppers", although I wouldn't say it is a particularly good one. --'''''[[User:Jasca Ducato|Jasca Ducato]]''''' [[User talk:Jasca Ducato|Council Chamber]] [[Special:Contributions/Jasca_Ducato|Assassination record]] 21:36, October 6, 2010 (UTC)
{{voteclosed end}}

==[[User:Campbell430|Campbell430]]==

I think I have proven myself to be worthy to join the Istruttori because I have Started to Create the Memories pages, created quite a lot of locations pages, added loads of images to pages, helped other users and I feel that I have matured greatly since I joined this wiki. I hope this will make you vote Yay.
===Yay===
# Helped me alot in the memory project, does great contributions and starting to give advice to new editors, it would just be cruel not to accept him. [[User:DanMan7308|DanMan7308]] 16:55, October 31, 2010 (UTC) DanMan7308
# Has made some really valuable contributions by now and has shown himself to be a good community man. He's got my vote. -- [[User:Master Sima Yi|Master Sima Yi]] 17:06, October 31, 2010 (UTC)
# Active. Responsive. Good edits. Respectful. I approve. Hope you don't disappoint once you get the job. [[Special:Contributions/121.54.54.34|121.54.54.34]] 17:40, October 31, 2010 (UTC)

===Nay===

Assassin's Creed Wiki - User contributions [en-gb]

Assassin's Creed Wiki:Bureau/MembersNom